New Delhi (By Bratatee Pradhan):
The Supreme Court on Friday refused to stay the bail granted to Sonam
Raghuvanshi, the prime accused in the high-profile Raja Raghuvanshi
honeymoon murder case, while agreeing to examine the Meghalaya
government’s plea challenging the order. Although the apex court
expressed reservations over the reasoning adopted by the Meghalaya High
Court in granting bail, it held that there was no justification for immediately
sending the accused back to jail after she had already been released.
A bench comprising Justice M.M. Sundresh and Justice Sheel Nagu issued
notice to Sonam Raghuvanshi and sought her response to the Meghalaya
government’s appeal. The court observed that once an accused has been
released on bail, an interim stay of the bail order is generally not the
appropriate remedy. Instead, it decided to hear the matter in detail after the
court’s vacation.
The Meghalaya government, represented by Solicitor General Tushar
Mehta, strongly opposed Sonam’s release, arguing that the allegations
against her involve a meticulously planned murder and should not have
been overlooked due to what it described as a mere procedural lapse.
Mehta termed the High Court’s decision “shocking” and maintained that
the seriousness of the offence outweighed any clerical error in the arrest
documents.
The controversy revolves around an error in the police records prepared at
the time of Sonam’s arrest. The arrest memo and related documents
mentioned Section 403(1) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) instead of
Section 103(1), which deals with the offence of murder. The trial court had
ruled that this mistake meant the grounds of arrest were not properly
communicated to the accused, thereby violating her constitutional rights.
The Meghalaya High Court upheld this reasoning while refusing to interfere
with the bail order.
The state government, however, argued before the Supreme Court that the
mistake was purely typographical and caused no prejudice to Sonam, as
she was fully aware that she had been arrested in connection with the
murder of her husband. It pointed out that the transit remand order and
other proceedings clearly indicated the nature of the allegations and that
such clerical mistakes should not become the basis for granting bail in a
murder case.
During the hearing, the Supreme Court questioned certain aspects of the
High Court’s reasoning and indicated that it had prima facie reservations
regarding the legal basis for the order. At the same time, the bench declined
to suspend Sonam’s bail, observing that she had already been released
and was complying with the conditions imposed by the trial court.
The case has attracted nationwide attention since the death of Raja
Raghuvanshi, a businessman from Indore. Raja and Sonam had married in
May 2025 and travelled to Meghalaya for their honeymoon. The couple
went missing shortly after arriving in Sohra (Cherrapunji), and Raja’s body
was later recovered from a deep gorge. Investigators alleged that Sonam
conspired with her alleged lover, Raj Kushwaha, and hired assailants to
murder Raja during the trip. Police claim the conspiracy was pre-planned
and supported by electronic evidence, witness statements, CCTV footage
and financial records.
Sonam was arrested from Uttar Pradesh several days after Raja’s body was
found, while multiple co-accused were also taken into custody. The
prosecution has since filed a detailed chargesheet running into hundreds
of pages, and the trial is underway with dozens of witnesses expected to
testify.
The Supreme Court’s refusal to stay the bail order means Sonam
Raghuvanshi will continue to remain out on bail for the time being.
However, the court has agreed to hear the Meghalaya government’s appeal
seeking cancellation of her bail. The final outcome of that hearing could
determine whether the procedural error relied upon by the lower courts is
sufficient to justify bail in a case involving allegations of a carefully planned
murder.
Subscribe to Updates
Get the latest creative news from FooBar about art, design and business.
Supreme Court refuses to stay Sonam Raghuvanshi’s bail in Honeymoon Murder Case
Related Posts
Add A Comment

